When you're selling your home, choosing the right estate agent is one of the biggest decisions you'll make.
You want someone who knows your local property market, markets your home properly, negotiates the best possible price and keeps everything moving once you've accepted an offer.
But there's another important consideration: how much is it actually going to cost you?
Estate agent fees can vary significantly, and one of the biggest differences is how agents charge for their services.
Some charge a percentage of your property's final selling price, while others offer a fixed fee, so you know exactly what you'll pay from the beginning.
But what's the difference? Is one better than the other? And could choosing a fixed-fee estate agent save you thousands?
Let's break it down.
What Is a Percentage-Based Estate Agent?
A percentage-based estate agent charges a fee calculated as a percentage of your home's final selling price.
For example, if your estate agent charges 1.5% plus VAT and your home sells for £300,000, their fee would be £5,400 including VAT.
The more your home sells for, the higher the estate agent's fee.
Percentage-based fees vary depending on the agent, the property, the location and the services included.
For illustration, fees of 1% to 2.5% plus VAT would produce the following costs:
| Selling Price | 1% + VAT | 1.5% + VAT | 2.5% + VAT |
|---|---|---|---|
| £200,000 | £2,400 | £3,600 | £6,000 |
| £300,000 | £3,600 | £5,400 | £9,000 |
| £400,000 | £4,800 | £7,200 | £12,000 |
| £500,000 | £6,000 | £9,000 | £15,000 |
All figures include VAT at 20%. These are illustrative fee rates, not a verified average of what estate agents currently charge in South Wales.
As you can see, the cost of selling your home can increase considerably as the property value rises.
Are There Benefits to Percentage-Based Fees?
There can be.
Some homeowners like the idea that their agent's fee increases if they achieve a higher selling price.
However, it's worth looking at how much that incentive is actually worth.
If your home sells for an additional £10,000 and your agent charges 1.5% plus VAT, their fee increases by just £180 including VAT.
The homeowner benefits from the vast majority of that extra selling price.
So while a percentage-based fee can create a financial incentive, the quality of an agent's marketing, negotiation skills and service is arguably far more important than how their fee is calculated.
What Is a Fixed-Fee Estate Agent?
A fixed-fee estate agent charges an agreed amount for selling your property, rather than calculating their fee as a percentage of the final sale price.
For example, at Urban Suburban, our standard estate agency fee is £2,500 + VAT (£3,000 including VAT).
Whether your home sells for £250,000, £300,000 or £400,000, that standard fee stays the same, provided the agreed terms don't change.
This gives homeowners certainty about their estate agency costs from the beginning.
However, not all fixed-fee estate agents operate in the same way.
Some offer lower-cost online packages where homeowners may need to conduct their own viewings, pay upfront or purchase additional services.
Others, like Urban Suburban, provide a full estate agency service for a fixed fee.
That's why it's important to compare what's included, not just the headline price.
Fixed-Fee vs Percentage-Based Estate Agents: A Cost Comparison
Let's look at how the two fee structures compare using Urban Suburban's standard fixed fee of £3,000 including VAT and an illustrative percentage-based fee of 1.5% plus VAT.
| Property Selling Price | Percentage Fee | Urban Suburban Fixed Fee | Potential Saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| £200,000 | £3,600 | £3,000 | £600 |
| £250,000 | £4,500 | £3,000 | £1,500 |
| £300,000 | £5,400 | £3,000 | £2,400 |
| £350,000 | £6,300 | £3,000 | £3,300 |
| £400,000 | £7,200 | £3,000 | £4,200 |
| £500,000 | £9,000 | £3,000 | £6,000 |
All fees include VAT at 20%. Savings are illustrative and depend on the percentage rate quoted by the alternative agent. Urban Suburban's standard fee is used for comparison; individual quotations may differ.
For a homeowner selling at £350,000, the difference could be £3,300.
That's £3,300 you could put towards moving costs, furnishing your next home or simply keeping more of your hard-earned equity.
And the higher your property's selling price, the greater the potential saving against a percentage-based fee at the same rate.
Does a Fixed Fee Mean a Cheaper Service?
This is probably one of the biggest misconceptions about fixed-fee estate agents.
Some homeowners assume that if an estate agent charges less, they must be offering less.
But that's not necessarily the case.
The fee structure tells you how an agent charges. It doesn't automatically tell you how good their service will be.
A fixed-fee estate agent can still offer professional photography, property videos, floorplans, Rightmove and Zoopla advertising, accompanied viewings, negotiation and sales progression.
Equally, paying a higher percentage fee doesn't automatically guarantee better marketing or a higher selling price.
The important question isn't simply how much an estate agent charges. It's what you're getting for your money.
Before choosing an agent, ask to see examples of their property marketing, understand how they manage enquiries and viewings, and find out how they'll support you once a sale has been agreed.
What's Included in Urban Suburban's Fixed Fee?
At Urban Suburban, we believe selling your home should come with great marketing, excellent service and a fee that's clear from the start.
Our standard fixed-fee service includes:
-
Professional property photography and video marketing
-
Floorplans and engaging property descriptions
-
Advertising on Rightmove and Zoopla
-
Social media marketing to help your home reach more potential buyers
-
Management of buyer enquiries and viewings
-
Feedback and updates throughout the selling process
-
Offer negotiation
-
Sales progression support once a buyer has been found
We also use the Street app, giving sellers convenient access to their property sale, including viewing requests and feedback.
And importantly, we don't ask for an upfront estate agency fee or lock sellers into a tie-in period.
You get the support of a local estate agent, professional marketing and a clear fee structure.
Do Fixed-Fee Estate Agents Work as Hard to Get the Best Price?
It's a fair question.
If an estate agent receives the same fee regardless of your final selling price, will they still be motivated to negotiate the best possible offer?
We believe a good estate agent's motivation should go far beyond earning a slightly higher commission.
Our reputation depends on delivering results, providing a great experience and earning recommendations from happy customers.
And there's another important point.
A percentage-based agent charging 1.5% plus VAT earns just £90 more including VAT if they negotiate an additional £5,000 on your selling price.
For you, that extra £5,000 could make a meaningful difference to your next move.
The most important things are your agent's negotiation skills, understanding of buyer demand and commitment to achieving the best outcome.
That's what homeowners should be looking for, regardless of whether the fee is fixed or percentage-based.
Is a Fixed-Fee Estate Agent Always Cheaper?
Not necessarily.
For lower-value properties, a percentage-based fee could sometimes work out cheaper than a particular fixed-fee package.
For example, on a £150,000 property, an agent charging 1% plus VAT would cost £1,800 including VAT, compared with a fixed fee of £3,000 including VAT.
There may also be differences in the services offered, minimum fees, contract terms or additional charges.
That's why it's important to compare the total cost and the service you'll receive.
At Urban Suburban, we'll always explain our fee clearly so you can make an informed decision.
What Should You Ask Before Choosing an Estate Agent?
Whether you're considering a fixed-fee or percentage-based estate agent, there are a few important questions worth asking.
1. Is VAT Included in the Quoted Fee?
Always check whether the figure you're given includes VAT.
A fee of 1.5% plus VAT is actually 1.8% of your final selling price.
That difference can add up to hundreds or thousands of pounds.
2. Are There Any Upfront Costs?
Some estate agents charge upfront for marketing or particular services.
Make sure you understand what you'll need to pay and when.
3. Is There a Tie-In Period?
Some agency agreements include a minimum contract period.
Ask how long you're committed for and what happens if you decide to change agents.
4. What's Included in the Marketing?
Will your home have professional photography, video, floorplans and social media promotion?
How will the agent make your property stand out against competing homes?
5. Who Will Handle Your Viewings and Negotiations?
Find out whether the agent will accompany viewings, provide feedback and negotiate offers on your behalf.
6. What Happens Once a Sale Is Agreed?
Agreeing a sale is only part of the process.
A good estate agent should continue supporting you and helping communication between the parties until completion.
Fixed-Fee vs Percentage-Based Estate Agents: Which Is Better?
There's no single answer for every homeowner.
A percentage-based agent may offer a competitive quote for some properties, while a fixed-fee agent can provide greater cost certainty and potentially substantial savings, particularly on higher-value homes.
Ultimately, the right estate agent is the one who can demonstrate local knowledge, strong marketing, effective negotiation and a service you feel confident in.
Our advice is simple: don't choose an estate agent based on the fee alone, but don't assume paying more means you're getting more either.
Look at the full picture.
Thinking About Selling Your Home in South Wales?
Whether you're selling in Cardiff, Newport, Bridgend, Port Talbot or Porthcawl, it's worth knowing exactly what you'll pay before putting your property on the market.
At Urban Suburban, our standard fixed estate agency fee is £2,500 + VAT, with no upfront estate agency fee and no tie-in period.
We combine local property knowledge with professional marketing, straightforward communication and a personal approach to selling homes.
And we believe you shouldn't have to pay thousands more in estate agency fees simply because your home is worth more.
Thinking about selling?
Before committing to an estate agent, find out what your home could be worth and how much you could save.
Book your free, no-obligation property valuation with Urban Suburban today. We'd love to show you what we can do for your home.
Share this article
Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe to receive the latest property market information to your inbox, full of market knowledge and tips for your home.
You may unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

